German Potential

The new Germany is here. After decades of being pigeonholed as a specialist in sweet wines, Germany has emerged as one of the world's most dynamic wine regions, producing dry wines of exceptional precision while maintaining its mastery of traditional styles. Climate change has paradoxically enhanced Germany's ability to create world-class wines across all styles - from ethereal Kabinetts to powerful Grosses Gewächs dry wines and sophisticated Pinot Noirs. The six producers featured in this "German Potential" tasting represent this transformation: Bürklin-Wolf pioneering biodynamic viticulture in the Pfalz, Seckinger pushing boundaries with extended macerations, Moritz Kissinger crafting Burgundian-style Chardonnays, Hofgut Falkenstein maintaining radical non-interventionist traditions, Dönnhoff setting benchmarks in the Nahe, and Wasenhaus bringing Burgundian sensibilities to Baden. Each demonstrates how Germany's unique combination of diverse terroirs, evolving climate conditions, and innovative winemaking philosophies has created an unprecedented golden age for German wine.

Understanding modern German wine law and its evolution

German wine classification underwent its most significant transformation since 1971 with the 2021 wine law (effective 2026), shifting from a ripeness-based to a terroir-based system. The traditional Prädikatswein hierarchy remains, with its six levels based on must weights: Kabinett (67-82° Oechsle), Spätlese (76-90°), Auslese (83-100°), Beerenauslese (110-128°), Eiswein (110-128°, harvested at -7°C), and Trockenbeerenauslese (150-154°). However, these now indicate grape ripeness at harvest, not final wine sweetness - a critical distinction as 60% of German production is now dry.

The VDP (Verband Deutscher Prädikatsweingüter) classification, representing 200 elite estates, operates on Burgundian principles with four tiers: VDP.Gutswein (regional), VDP.Ortswein (village), VDP.Erste Lage (Premier Cru, maximum 60 hl/ha), and VDP.Grosse Lage (Grand Cru, maximum 50 hl/ha). The prestigious Grosses Gewächs (GG) designation marks dry wines from Grand Cru sites, requiring hand-harvesting, traditional methods, and extended ageing. The 2021 law democratises this system, allowing all producers to use Erstes/Grosses Gewächs designations if they meet stringent requirements, including hand-harvesting, yield restrictions, and blind tasting approval.

Germany's 13 wine regions (Anbaugebiete) span from the tiny Ahr (500 hectares) specialising in Pinot Noir to massive Rheinhessen (26,500 hectares) producing diverse styles. The Mosel remains the export powerhouse with 60% Riesling plantings on steep slate slopes, while warmer regions like Baden and Pfalz increasingly excel with both traditional and international varieties.

Climate change transforms German viticulture fundamentally

Germany has experienced dramatic warming over 40+ years, with the three hottest summers in recorded history (2003, 2018, 2019) all producing blockbuster vintages. Average potential alcohol levels rose 26% between 1970-1986 and 1994-2010, while flowering now occurs 10-15 days earlier than in 1955. This warming enables unprecedented opportunities: red wine production stabilised at 34% of plantings (up from 17% fifty years ago), Germany ranks third globally in Pinot Noir plantings, and new regions as far north as Sylt island (55°N) now produce wine.

However, challenges mount equally fast. 2019 marked the first year without any Eiswein production across all German states - a historic loss. Extreme weather events multiply: devastating floods destroyed 60 of 65 Ahr wineries in July 2021, while the 2022 vintage experienced the driest conditions on record. Producers adapt through precision viticulture: strategic canopy management reduces sugar accumulation, irrigation infrastructure becomes standard in new plantings, and many move to higher elevations and north-facing slopes seeking cooler conditions.

The fundamental identity of German wine shifts from cool-climate specialist to versatile producer. Winemakers now prioritise acid retention over maximum ripeness, employ aggressive leaf removal (25% canopy reduction), and embrace climate-resistant varieties covering 3,500 hectares. Consumer preferences evolved dramatically - Germans now strongly prefer dry wines, with trocken styles dominating restaurant lists since the 1990s. The challenge becomes maintaining Germany's unique position while adapting to unstable climate realities.

Four remarkable vintages showcase Germany's adaptability

The 2019-2023 period demonstrates German producers' resilience through extreme conditions. 2019 emerged as "one of the greatest vintages of modern times" according to James Suckling, despite record-breaking heat reaching 40°C+. The vintage combined exceptional ripeness with surprising acidity, producing multiple 100-point wines. Stuart Pigott called it "the best vintage I have ever tasted for German Riesling in my four-decade career." Cornelius Dönnhoff noted its "classic German vintage acidity structure like 2001, but combined with much more ripeness." However, warm winter conditions meant no Eiswein was produced - a historic first.

2021 marked a cool-climate throwback after devastating July floods in the Ahr valley. Despite challenges including the most expensive farming conditions in living memory due to disease pressure, the vintage produced outstanding Kabinett wines with "racy, electric, spine-tingling" character. A Wehlen Sonnenuhr Kabinett achieved a record €405 at auction, reflecting the vintage's ethereal quality. Total acidity levels reached heights "unheard of this decade."

The 2022 "miraculous vintage" survived the driest year on record through crucial September rains that "saved the vintage." Despite extreme heat and drought causing vine dormancy, wines emerged surprisingly cool and elegant with 10-11% alcohol levels in many dry Rieslings. The VDP praised "remarkably nuanced wines with perfect acidity levels and striking aromatics."

2023 combined all elements - what Justerini & Brooks called an "exciting, incisive vintage with poise and symmetry only Riesling can deliver." The vintage produced both exceptional dry wines and the best noble sweet wines since 2019, with producers noting it "has it all" - combining previous vintages' best characteristics.

Six producers illustrate Germany's new potential

Bürklin-Wolf elevates Pfalz terroir through biodynamic excellence

Wachenheimer Gerümpel P.C. showcases Bürklin-Wolf's revolutionary approach to German wine. This 13-hectare vineyard (Bürklin-Wolf owns 6.2 hectares) features red and yellow Buntsandstein (weathered sandstone) with significant basalt influences from neighbouring Forster Pechstein, earning it the nickname "kleiner Pechstein" (little Pechstein). First documented in 1429, the site benefits from föhn-like warming winds that reduce fungal pressure.

Birgit Bürklin transformed the estate into Germany's first Biodyvin-certified producer in 2005, implementing rigorous biodynamic practices. The P.C. (Premier Cru) designation reflects their Burgundian classification based on the 1828 Royal Bavarian Classification, rejecting the Prädikatswein system for pure terroir expression. Fermentation occurs spontaneously - 50% in large old oak casks (600-3000L Stockinger and Mattern) and 50% in stainless steel. Wines age on lees until June following harvest, with Premier Crus bottled earlier than Grand Crus to preserve freshness.

Seckinger pushes boundaries with radical natural winemaking

The "1 Tal" vineyard represents Seckinger's most extreme site - a 0.5-hectare parcel in a cool side valley that's "almost continuously shaded". Historically too cold for ripening, climate change now enables this unique terroir to shine. The red and yellow Buntsandstein creates complex minerality enhanced by the site's natural high acidity.

Jonas and Dorothee Seckinger employ 3-5 days skin contact on foot-crushed whole clusters, necessary to balance the extreme natural acidity. Fermentation proceeds spontaneously for 12+ months in used Tonneaux, creating an intentionally oxidative style influenced by Jura techniques. As part of their "R Pure" range, the wine sees no added sulfur, no fining, and no filtration - "zero outside tampering and plenty of time in the barrel make wines naturally stable." Their certified biodynamic farming and radical non-intervention create wines of uncommon character and longevity.

Moritz Kissinger brings Burgundian precision to Rheinhessen Chardonnay

From a mere 0.15 hectares in the Tafelstein vineyard, Uelversheim, Moritz Kissinger crafts Chardonnay that rivals Burgundy's best. The 26-year-old vines root deep in limestone and loess at the Rhine front, providing perfect air circulation and mineral intensity. This high limestone content creates the structure and tension defining his wines.

Kissinger's Demeter-certified biodynamic approach emphasises minimal intervention. Spontaneous fermentation occurs in 2nd and 3rd use French oak (225L and 500L barrels) - he was "forced" to use older barrels as new ones went to his debut vintage, discovering this created his signature elegance. After 12 months in oak, wines spend 6 months in stainless steel. Extended lees contact for 10 months develops texture without bâtonnage, while minimal sulfur additions at bottling preserve the wine's natural expression.

Hofgut Falkenstein maintains Saar's most radical traditions

Johannes Weber's "kontrolliertes nichts tun" (controlled non-intervention) philosophy produces Germany's most distinctive wines. The Ober Schäfershaus site occupies 0.2 hectares within Krettnacher Altenberg, featuring grey slate with quartz and diabase (green basaltic rock). Euchariusberg, considered a "mini-Scharzhofberg," comprises 2.2 hectares of 40-50-year-old vines on grey slate with quartzite-bearing sandstones.

Weber's winemaking borders on the mystical: spontaneous fermentation by ambient yeasts in a deep, damp cellar with mouldy stone walls, ageing in traditional 1000L Fuder casks (some historic from Niedermennig's former mayor), and absolutely no sulfur additions during or after fermentation - relying on pH under 3 for stability. Wines remain on full gross lees until bottling in March-May with no racking or pumping. Each Fuder is bottled separately, preserving individual cask character. No chaptalisation, concentration, de-acidification, enzymes, or stabilisers ever touch these wines.

Dönnhoff sets Nahe benchmarks from historic Kahlenberg

Kahlenberg vineyard in Bad Kreuznach, documented since 1499, features unusual gravelly loam with quartzite inclusions giving wines a characteristic spicy character. The "naked mountain" (lacking tree coverage) faces due south in the lower Nahe course. It historically served as a reference site for the Royal Prussian Institute of Pomology and Viticulture.

Helmut Dönnhoff's approach balances tradition with precision. Fermentation combines stainless steel and 1000L Stückfass oak barrels made by cooper Hösch using Lemberg forest wood, with staves twice the normal thickness and seasoned 7-12 years for absolute neutrality. Native yeasts ferment each site individually. With 25-45-year-old vines yielding just 45 hl/ha, organic farming practices, and decisions "made by taste, not analytics," Dönnhoff creates wines of exceptional purity. Riesling never sees new oak - the first three passes go to Weiss and Grauburgunder.

Wasenhaus imports Burgundian methods to Baden

Christoph Wolber and Alexander Götze, trained at Burgundy's elite estates (Pierre Morey, de Montille, Leflaive), founded Wasenhaus in 2016 to apply these lessons to Baden's diverse terroirs. Their Mohlin vineyard 2019 Weissburgunder comes from 1950s plantings that technically aren't pure Weissburgunder - French nursery mistakes created field blends including Gutedel and Chardonnay.

The higher limestone content in Mohlin creates structure, while typical Baden diversity adds complexity. Using a traditional Spindelpresse basket press for whole clusters, primary fermentation occurs in small wooden barrels with native yeasts. The 2019 spent 12 months on full lees in oak, then 6 months in stainless steel with fine lees promoting vibrancy. Bottled without clearing, filtering, or sulfite additions, the wine exemplifies their natural approach. With just 2.5 hectares supplemented by purchased organic grapes, they maintain 30-50 ppm total sulfur - applied only after malolactic fermentation.

Brand Bros Pétillant Naturel Blanc 2023

Opens with a breeze of cider apples and salty citrus, somewhere between pink grapefruit zest and wind off a cold sea. The palate is clean and mineral - think crushed oyster shells dusted with sea salt. But there's more going on beneath: hints of meadow herbs, white blossoms, a flicker of honey, and a savoury yeastiness that rounds things out. The bubbles are fine yet nervy, the acidity bright. It's brisk, unpolished, and a little wild. Not well composed, but drinks effortlessly.

Seckinger 1 Tal Riesling 2021

Striking from the first sniff - there's depth and a kind of smoky elegance: bitumen, toasted sesame, buttered croissant, and bitter herbs stitched together with a salty edge. The bouquet feels rich yet composed, like something slowly unfolding rather than shouting for attention. On the palate, it's tight and racy, with chalky texture and a firm saline grip. There's real structure here, but also grace - dense, layered, and deeply savoury. It keeps evolving, never quite sitting still. A unique Riesling that commands focus without forcing it - and easily the wine that stayed with me longest that night.

Hofgut Falkenstein Krettnacher Ober Schäfershaus Riesling Spätlese trocken 2023

Textbook Saar (to my limited understanding) - all ripe apple, puff pastry, and a touch of butter, like a still-warm chausson aux pommes. Flint and salt give it backbone, and there's that quiet, steely elegance that feels almost inevitable here. The residual sugar is perfectly judged - just enough to round the edges without softening the grip. Dense but not heavy, mineral but not austere. It's precise, savoury, and deeply satisfying - even if, coming after a more dramatic wine, it plays a little safer. Still, beauty in restraint.

Dönnhoff Kreuznach Erste Lage Riesling Kahlenberg 2022

A clean, composed Riesling with all the right moves - stone fruits, citrus zest, yellow apple, and a floral lift that's almost springlike. There's a dusting of white pepper, a trace of honey, and that classic wet stone feel beneath it all. Bone-dry and juicy, with a subtle saltiness and a touch of oiliness that gives weight to the mid-palate. It's precise and elegant, but somehow a little aloof - complex, yes, but not particularly expressive just yet. Slight bitterness on the finish is interesting though. Feels like something waiting to come into focus.

Bürklin-Wolf Wachenheimer Gerümpel P.C. Riesling Trocken 2022

A clear and chiselled expression - flinty and saline, with crushed stone aromas taking the lead. Fruit sits in the background: yellow apple, golden pear, a brush of apricot, all in muted tones. There's a faint smokiness, and the softest hint of butter sneaking through, just enough to warm the edges. On the palate it's vibrant and chalky, with a limey zip and taut structure that keeps everything in line. Focused, upright, and precise - a wine that feels like it knows exactly where it's going.

Wasenhaus Möhlin 2019

It opens with a promise - that quiet Wasenhaus elegance, fine mineral tension, and a lovely saline thread that pulls you in. There's a whisper of fermenty tang, beautifully controlled, and the fruit - what there is - feels etched rather than painted. Texturally it's graceful, layered, and gently rich. But still, something's missing. It doesn't quite cohere around a centre - as if the core has been hollowed out or hasn't yet arrived. A lovely wine, no doubt, but at this price and pedigree, you find yourself wanting it to say more.

Moritz Kissinger Chardonnay 2022

Bright and expressive from the start - ripe apples, lemon zest, key lime, and a whisper of vanilla set the tone. But it's the reductive edge that makes it stand out: sesame, warm popcorn, a touch of struck match. On the palate, it crackles with energy - high acidity, mineral salinity, and that chalky, limestone grip that carries everything forward. Fruit stays crisp and concentrated, with oak playing a quiet supporting role - just enough to add creaminess and frame the structure without muting the freshness. It feels precise, alive, and confidently made. A wine with real character, but no need to shout.

Hofgut Falkenstein Krettnacher Euchariusberg Riesling Auslese 2023

Crystalline and sharp, this Auslese leans more toward tension than indulgence. It's cool and fresh, almost airy, with a clarity that borders on surgical. Aromatically, it's a green spectrum - underripe pineapple, quince, starfruit, and mint, laced with bergamot and a faint floral breeze. There's something both delicate and driven here. The sweetness is dialled back, letting the acidity and stony core take centre stage. Citrus and peach flicker through, but the real story is in the mineral charge and the precision of the structure. A wine of energy and restraint - taut, not lush.

Conclusion

These six producers exemplify Germany's transformation from a sweet wine specialist to one of the world's most exciting and diverse wine regions. Climate change, while presenting challenges, has unlocked potential previously unimaginable - from Burgundian-style Chardonnays in limestone-rich Rheinhessen to profound dry Rieslings from sites once too cool for consistent ripening. The combination of ancient vineyard sites, cutting-edge sustainable viticulture, and winemakers unafraid to push boundaries while respecting tradition creates wines of unprecedented quality and character.

The new German wine law's shift to terroir-based classification acknowledges what these producers have long practised - that place matters more than sugar levels. As global wine preferences evolve toward lower alcohol, higher acidity, and site-specific character, Germany finds itself perfectly positioned. The 2019-2023 vintages demonstrate that whether facing drought, floods, or perfect conditions, German producers consistently craft wines of elegance, precision, and longevity.

The future belongs to producers like these six, who understand that Germany's greatest strength lies not in mimicking other regions but in expressing the unique convergence of climate, soil, and human vision that makes German wine irreplaceable in the world's cellars. From Falkenstein's radical non-intervention to Kissinger's Burgundian precision, from Bürklin-Wolf's biodynamic revolution to Seckinger's natural wine experiments, German wine has never been more essential or exciting.

Raw scores